Basic Land Update

As mentioned before, I tend to obsess slightly over lands. I’m not entirely sure why, but I’ve always enjoyed them. Perhaps it’s the good mix of landscapes (always a favorite) with Magic cards, a beautiful Venn diagram if there ever was one. Anyway, this manifests itself in various ways: pages of dual-lands in my binder (a shocking percentage of my “trade” binder is–in fact–not for trade) and my obsessive curation of basic lands.

But I come not to bury Caesar, but rather celebrate an additional piece to the puzzle. Rebecca Guay basic land art!

Read more

M25 Draft Results

Hosted an M25 draft on Sunday and it was a genuine bucket of fun. Mostly just a really good excuse to play with some broken cards and we opened some doozies. But most importantly, it was an excuse to dress up the Baby Raptor.

signal-2018-03-18-174241 Read more

M25 Theorycraft

Hosting an M25 draft on Sunday (there may also be freshly baked cookies, recipe to follow) so it’s time to do a little theorycraft in case LR can’t come to my rescue fast enough. As per usual, I like to look to the gold cards for guidance.

cloudblazerOkay, a classic of the genre! Also a pretty good indicator of some blink shenanigans, so let’s see what enablers (and other quality ETBs) we have in UW.

Okay, so there are some decent mechanics but only one flicker effect? What the hell? This does not looks like a ‘major theme’ to me. Let’s try another.

watchwolf1Okay, well, that’s… super vanilla. A perfectly decent card with absolutely no guiding abilities. Let’s break down the pieces we have in each other. Being green we have ramp (not pictured: decent morphs and 6-drops worth ramping into)

We have some go-wide stuff

The golds are… not helpful actually. Hmmm, let’s jump to red. Hey look, more go-wide!

Some traditional blue-pairing with instants-and-sorceries-matter

Okay, okay, this feels a little more helpful. Blue?

This is actually a pretty fair representation of what blue has to offer: card draw, evasive threats, and tappers. Frequently they combine two of three! I think this is starting to be what M25 is trying to do: pushing less clear-cut tribal synergies and more a pure manifestation of what each color does. Green: ramp, big creatures. Blue: control. Red: lots of direct damage and little creatures. Let’s take a look at black

Murder, sacrifice shenanigans, and graveyard stuff. All the black classics!

So here’s my TLDR, and whoa hey look, LR just came out with their m25 preview so I better mash publish quickly before this turns into (even more) of a thinly veiled regurgitation of their insights. A deck will need A Plan, either go wide, go big, or go long. Spew out a bunch of 1/1s and pump your whole team. Ramp out a monstrously huge creature that demands answers. Or play UBER-style, control, gain some card advantage and kill your opponent with an evasive creature. Combine the colors with the building blocks that work. So black/red will could use a bunch of small creatures to fuel some Atog-ish win conditions. Red/green has really great go-wide pieces. Green/black ramps to something big. Just about anything with blue uses card advantage (with a *possible* exception for UR spells) to push a long-game plan.

Red: Direct damage removal, go-wide, spells-matter
Blue: card draw, evasive threats, counterspelling
Black: sacrifice, “Aristocrats”, hard removal, graveyard
White: small creatures, defense, enchantments
Green: ramp, big creatures, small creature fuel

There is very little splash enabling.

Ash Barren is uncommon, PP is at common (which is something I guess) and Myriad landscape is more of a ramping card than a splash enabler. So find your open seat and draft heavy on value with an eye to the synergies mentioned above. Oh, I guess there is ONE combo deck.

Assembly Workers! They are at common so you WILL see them. Not sure if the table can support two of these guys but it could be potentially hilarious if there’s no compelling first pick.

Channel Naptime 3-3-18

The Raptor Hatchling went down for a nap right on schedule (given the ease of her as a baby right now, I’m going to be karmically punished hard come the teenage years, I can just tell already) so it’s time to frantically squeeze in a draft! Going to try and shake off all of Chris’s bad mojo and try to build something respectable. Unfortunately I forgot to capture the draft log (had to reinstall MTGO) so you just have the video plus some highlighted picks.

Pack 1 Pick 1

Well that’s not the most inspiring set of cardsto open but… serviceable. Interestingly, I think the most recent episode of Limited Resources had a Forerunner vs. Waterknot debate. I take the removal. I’m not wild about how unsplashable it is (compared to say, Luminous Bonds) but it is good removal and is good in every deck.

Read more

Introducing the raptor hatchling

A brief introduction to my daughter, the Raptor Hatchling (her fault for inventing a weird, guttural screech when hungry). Born in August, she has proven to be a delightful addition to the family. Her mother–perhaps foolishly–has deferred an awful lot of the naming conventions to me. Thus the stuffies now have names like Paladine, Elune, &c. It’s not her sleep sack, it’s her Robe of Protection +2. Her sleep-song is from Final Fantasy IX (You’re Not Alone) And so forth.

But first we must ask: who wore it better?

 

 

Channel CJed 2-24-18

Let’s break in this channel with some throwback CJed action! Had a great binge with Chris on Saturday, broken up only by my computer throwing a gasket, dropping the connection, then politely requesting a fresh install of Windows. Fortunately the computer was really just protecting you, loyal viewer, as our drafts went RAPIDLY downhill.

Draft Viewer

 

A respectable finish, though certainly not one for the recordbooks. Broken unbeatable rare is broken and unbeatable! I did like how we totally failed on the ‘alpha’ strike, not realizing that the first-strike damage would turn all of our mighty 3/3 Saprolings into 1/1 pumpkins. This is what happens when I’m left unsupervised.

Other lessons from the binge and horrific drafts were missing more subtle signals. Yes, it’s one thing when pretty good removal comes to you 4th & 5th pick, but it’s another when a very good Vampire wheels around the table and is available 9th. Even if black isn’t “open” in your seat, a strong signal that no one else is in BW vampires is something worth considering very carefully.

The Journey Continues

You’re staring down a remorseless opponent, one absolutely dedicated to destroying this delicate equilibrium you’ve worked so hard to create. The clock is ticking and it appears you now have to face a wildly new set of threats and dangerous patterns than what you just got used to. What are you going to do?

Welcome to Benalish Dad, a blog dedicated to Magic cards, parenting hilarity, and the cross-section between the two. For reasons possibly linked to a mid-life crisis, I’ve really enjoyed delving into Magic cards lately. Of course time is also a premium and it’s difficult to explain to my offspring that dad is down to 11 minutes on his timer and he still has a third game to play. Maybe you want to chew on this toy instead of a while? No? Okay then, let me just mash F6 and see if I can come up with a different idea.

So this will be an area as I think about Magic cards (almost entirely Limited, barring some truly radical life change), post some drafts, occasionally throw in a picture of the Raptor Hatchling, and mess around with WordPress. Should be good times!

And yes, that is a Galaxy Quest reference for the post title. Well done